Sustainability Issue #3 October 2009

This is printed from sustainability.formas.se, last updated 9/24/2009 1:57:59 PM

Navigation

Change language

Search

Main content

PrintPrint
Ethical urban planning – is there such a thing?

Ethical pyramid. It is not ethical to let oneself be bribed, to lie and to take the credit for something one has not done oneself, write the authors in the book Ethics in planning. The sketch shows that ethics has different elements and different degrees of abstraction in planning. 

Ethical urban planning – is there such a thing?

In any case, there is a book entitled Ethics in urban planning. It was published as student literature in 2009 and is one of the results of the Formas-supported project New urbanism – the renaissance of ethics in Swedish urban planning.

The book is a textbook in planning and urban development and can also be read by professional planners. The authors are Marcus Johansson, PhD, political scientists and researcher at the Centre for Urban and Regional Studies at Örebro University, and Abdul Khakee, Professor Emeritus at the Department of Urban Planning and Environment, KTH in Stockholm and at Department of Political Sciences, Umeå University.

Johansson and Khakee do not only incline towards Aristotle and Chomsky. Ethical egoism is explained by the Wolf in the strip cartoon Bamse by Rune Andréason who thinks: It is only right when I get something, for all the others are egoists and think only of themselves. It is only I who think of myself.

Public interest the guiding principle

But Marcus Johansson and Abdul Khakee primarily investigate how urban planners who are civil servants reflect about ethical decisions. Both structure plans and building permit applications for private building are examined, and the book also contains a draft for the way ethics can be incorporated into the training of planners.

It is the duty of planners to ensure that political goals for building development and the provision of public service are implemented without being influenced by pressure by special interests and by their superiors. They must be attentive to the public and must explain their actions to their political masters.

Although the public interest is supposed to be the guiding principle in planning, the authors note that it is questionable whether there is any clear conception of what public interest comprises. – If planning is, on the whole, a political occupation, planning is a matter of power and the division of powers. They point out that this raises questions concerning equity and responsibility.

Literature:

More publications concerning urban planning are Just Environments – Politicising Sustainable Urban Development, a thesis by Karin Bradley who has recently received her doctorate in Environmental Justice at the Department of Urban Planning and Environment, KTH, and Equal opportunity next! Urban planning from a gender perspective, written by Anita Larsson and Anna Jalakas, and published by SNS Förlag.

Responsible for this page: Birgitta Bruzelius

Journal links

Sustainability October 2009

Focus presentation

When cities grow When cities grow, they become denser, higher and more extensive. People and activities come closer to one another. But not all. This may have good or bad results. In...

Focus articles

Urban research a priority theme for Formas Long term sustainable urban development demands increased awareness, broader knowledge and receptiveness to learning. Urban development also provides unique opportun... Broadens the perspective and increases funding More than ninety urban researchers from twelve countries are taking part in the massive investment made within the framework of the EU network Urban-net. Many Swedis... The climate changes the direction of tourist movements During future hot summers, more and more European tourists will want to come north. How will this affect the economy, environment and social development of European ... When will children be considered in urban planning? Children prefer to play near their homes. But they do not want to be sent only to play areas - they want to have access to the whole city. Children also want to be p... Compactness and parks are the future of the city We must face the fact that we do not at present have the means to manage the often segregated suburbs that were constructed for the welfare state. Those who live in ... Green wedges and urban commons Contiguous building development or contiguous green spaces? This is the question when plans are drawn up to make Stockholm the most attractive metropolitan region in...

The Interview

Existing buildings and sustainability Technical solutions which make things easier instead of pointing the finger which gives rise to a guilty conscience. This is what Janna Valik, Director General of th...

More articles

The sun in the centre at the seminar on climate According to IPCC, it is greenhouse gases that are to blame. But the sun, particles and clouds may also have an important part in climate changes. This issue was dis... Middle aged men have many foreign partners Generally speaking, male researchers have more international research partners than women, and men of upper middle age have more partners than younger men. On averag... Ethical urban planning – is there such a thing? In any case, there is a book entitled Ethics in urban planning. It was published as student literature in 2009 and is one of the results of the Formas-supported proj...

In brief

Clouds can predict the climate Measuring technique. In the centre of the photograph, a green laser beam can be seen behind the crest of a hill. The more intensely shining part of the beam shows... Europeans are buying GMO products Many Europeans are sceptical about foods from genetically modified organisms. But when they go shopping, they nevertheless buy foods with GMO labels. On the European... Midge bones reveal fish history The mandible of the phantom midge is microscopic. But in the hands of researchers at the Department of Zoology, Göteborg University, these midge bones become a time ... Alternative methods for animal experiments New in-vitro methods to find hormone disrupting substances. And to predict drug-induced liver injury, to analyse the effect of medicinal dosage and to be able to und... The Rural Landscapes of Europe – How man has shaped European nature As the six months of Swedish Presidency of the EU gets underway, the Swedish Research Council Formas is publishing an English edition of a book about the European cu...

Results from research

Difficult environmental choices for water and air How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... Visualise energy How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... Immigrant entrepreneurs in the urban built environment How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... Our daily bread How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... The language of flowers for life and death How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma...

Further links

Footer