Sustainability Issue #2 July 2009

This is printed from sustainability.formas.se, last updated 5/11/2009 6:19:49 PM

Navigation

Change language

Search

Main content

PrintPrint
There are no philosophers in research for society

Greater involvement by philosophers. Where are the philosophers? wonders Ola Engelmark. Social scientists study short term events, a few years or decades, natural scientists often work over a little longer time scale. But in order to create a sustainable future, we also need philosophers and other humanists with their knowledge of societies that are hundreds or thousands of years old, and of humanity's different needs. Ola Engelmark calls on philosophers to become more involved in the discussion on the development of society.  Photo: Denny Lorentzen

MISTRA's MD on environmental research

There are no philosophers in research for society

By Birgitta Bruzelius

On a bleak November day Sustainability meets Ola Engelmark, the MD of MISTRA, to have a talk on the mantra "research results belong to society". He has just come back from China and mentions the rapid growth of this country that is happening at the expense of their own living environment. This is one clear example of societal changes in which research for new knowledge can reduce the negative effects. But, on the whole, there are no philosophers involved.

Ola Engelmark took office as the new MD of MISTRA almost two years ago. He is working to bring about more clearly defined research prioritisations and greater competition for a research grant. More cooperation with the business sector and more humanities were on his wish list two years ago. How has it been since then?

You write in your latest annual report that you support research programmes which produce societal effects. In which area has your research been most successful?

- There are many areas. But I want to emphasise climate research, environmental technologies and ecosystem management. Other advances have been made in international air pollution control negotiations, industrial recycling and environmental chemistry.

- Climate research deals with modelling and adaptation by society, and also new knowledge for political negotiations, i.e. the Kyoto Protocol and its successors.

- The environmental technology research of MISTRA has yielded results such as the development of solar cells, fuel cells, more efficient diesel engines and non-fossil fuels, for example dimethyl ether (DME). DME can be produced by gasifying black liquor. If this technology proves successful and is expanded, Sweden can produce one third of the domestic demand for motor fuel, says Ola Engelmark.

The third successful area concerns the management of ecosystems. Examples of these are Vastra (Swedish Water Management Research Programme), Stockholm Resilience Center and Fjällmistra (Sustainable Management in the Mountain Region).

MISTRA's research on Sustainable capital management is also worth mentioning in view of the current "financial tsunami" in society. The capital market could invest both more environmentally and with a long term view. In this respect, we have taken a number of initiatives to develop knowledge and practice, so that capital can be invested with a view to promoting sustainable development. MISTRA's own capital is entirely managed on the basis of sustainability criteria.

In which sphere of society do you think that MISTRA's research may have great significance for development?

- Business development and knowledge for politicians and managers. Our research programmes deliver two alternative results. One is commercialisable results which is a new basis for the business sector, the development of new products and services. The other is knowledge for politicians and managers. In this way, all programmes are of significance for development in society.

One of your large research programmes is Hagmarksmistra (Management of Seminatural Grasslands) which has just ended after seven years. What significance will these research results have for the continued development of rural areas?

- They are important results. Agriculture and forestry in the countryside supply products and services to the rest of society. In order to understand how land can be managed in a long term sustainable manner, we need to study how land has been managed before. Knowledge about harvest, grazing and their effects on ecosystems and biodiversity are of critical importance in this respect. The reason why the landscape looks as it does is described very well in Hagmarksmistra. The way rural areas will be developed is now also highly dependent on EU decisions concerning grants.

Forestry also must develop new thinking concerning land use, says Ola Engelmark, and continues: - Society is facing serious challenges. Discussions are now going on about investments in diversity for outdoor activities, recreation and the other assets of the forest, instead of focusing, as before, on the production of timber. Social values are important. In order to meet the new need for knowledge, we are starting a new research programme, The forest of the future, next year.

- Forestry is one of the largest export industries of Sweden. How are the owners to manage this resource in a time of climate changes and globalisation? What new assets can be discovered, what can be improved? How can business development, recreation and biodiversity be combined? These are the issues that this research will examine.

When you took the post of MD for MISTRA almost two years ago, you said that you hoped for greater cooperation with the business sector. How has this worked out?

- Very well! The programme The forest of the future is one example of this. Over two years, the focus of this programme has been developed in cooperation with the business sector. It will now be jointly financed by MISTRA, all the large forestry companies, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences SLU, Umeå University and the Forestry Research Institute. To start with, more than MSEK 148 will be invested over four years. We are contributing forty per cent of this sum.

Other examples are Volvo's support for the development of fuel cells and the involvement of the forestry companies in developing the technology for black liquor gasification.

- The ambition of our large forthcoming action area Urban Futures which will be decided on next year is that it will be financed to the tune of fifty per cent by the users, i.e. municipalities and the business sector. Urban development is not only a matter of environmental technology, urban planning and transport. This programme will have a holistic approach and will give answers to questions such as: How to reduce the environmental impact while giving people an ever improving living environment? How can the city become attractive as regards integration, ethnic diversity and so on? How can the city contribute to sustainable growth?

You also wanted to elaborate how social sciences and the humanities can contribute to environmental issues. What has happened?

- We continue to work on environmental social science research. Political analysis and other social scientific knowledge are important for the management of environmental issues.

With regard to the humanities, there is a lot still to be done. Where are the philosophers? Social scientists study short term events, a few years or decades, natural scientists often work over a little longer time scale. But in order to create a sustainable future, we also need philosophers and other humanists with their knowledge of societies that are hundreds or thousands of years old, and of humanity's different needs. Ola Engelmark calls on philosophers to become more involved in the discussion on the development of society.

This year, you have started a research programme MISTRA-Swecia which is to study climate changes and the way society must adapt. It is a four year programme. What are your hopes for this?

- Great hopes. The climate is an issue of crucial importance after a growth in the national economy that is unparalleled.  But everything has a price, the environment and the climate have suffered from e.g. the emissions from fossil fuels. Climate changes cannot be simply switched off. We must adapt to them. If there will be more and more violent storms, if floods will occur more often, society must make plans to deal with these. The programme will be interdisciplinary. Political scientists, natural scientists and economists will work together to deliver results that can be used in specific cases in the real world.

Ola Engelmark also speaks of his collaboration with other research foundations. The assets of many of the world's foundations were accumulated during the last century. Decisions are now being taken to invest for the future. Ola Engelmark is in charge of work involving twenty foundations from different countries to coordinate future investments in research for the public good. The will and the money are there. We are now discussing how we are to prioritise our common efforts so as to increase the societal effects, says Ola Engelmark.

 

MISTRA

MISTRA, Foundation for Strategic Environmental Research, was formed in 1994 using the assets of the discontinued employees' funds. It must administer its capital to initiate and support research that prevents and solves environmental problems and at the same time develops society and the economy. A small secretariat of eight people is at the heart of the work. The annual investment in research is MSEK 200. Total assets amount to MSEK 3000. The Board, consisting of representatives of the research community, the business sector and non-profitmaking organisations, makes the decisions concerning research programmes and grants. Around 20 research programmes are in progress, with a total of 500 researchers and about the same number of practitioners.

 

Author :

Birgitta Bruzelius Editor in chief
E-mail: birgitta.bruzelius@formas.se

Related links

Responsible for this page: Birgitta Bruzelius

Journal links

Sustainability July 2009

Focus presentation

EU counters environmental threats with knowledge Biodiversity, climate conventions, climate-neutral energy, marine acidification, chemicals in the environment … the list of the areas where acute international solut...

Focus articles

Biodiversity – on several levels Genetic diversity within one species, diversity of species within an ecosystem, and diversity of ecosystems at global level are all essential for human existence. Re... What is the cost of biodiversity? What is the economic value of biodiversity for agriculture and forestry? The brief answer is SEK 2.60 per metre. But in order to delve a little more deeply into this... How did Animals cope before … and now? An international research project, CLIMIGRATE, is now starting, with the aim of investigating how different species responded to historic climate changes over the pa... Biodiversity in historical landscapes The historical landscape is of great significance for the numbers and types of plants we find today in our meadows and pastures. With the help of Sweden's unique map... Invasive species alter the plankton ecosystem Since 2007, extensive investigation of plankton in Gullmarsfjorden has been in progress in several projects financed by Formas and EU. The investigation was started ... Who is afraid of the wolf? Psychological factors are in many cases more important than objective facts for the attitudes and behaviours of people in relation to a sustainable development. An i... Genetic basis for sustainable fishing Pike, salmon and herring have widely different population structures. Different approaches are therefore needed to establish biologically sustainable management of t... Fungi provide nutrition for trees Soil is a globally limited resource which humanity needs for the production of food, fodder, fibres and biofuels. In the soil there are more than a thousand species ... Formas and the EU presidency During the time that Sweden has the presidency of the EU, the country is responsible for taking initiatives in a number of issues and to act as the host for many con... ERA-nets accelerate European research ERA-nets can be seen as the hothouse of European research, with couplings to the EU Commission. Formas is a member of over 10 ERA-nets and has been the member of sev... Conserve the usefulness and intrinsic value of species It is not enough to protect a certain flower, bird or meadow. We need a functioning ecological and social system which will do this. There is therefore a very great ... Exchange of researchers with Eastern Europe Cooperation with researchers in the EU obviously includes cooperation with researchers in the former Eastern Europe, both with EU members and with Russia. Leif Norrg... The feedback from viviparous blenny Lars Förlin and Joakim Larsson have cooperated for over ten years in various projects, with fish and environmental toxins as the common denominator. In one of their ... REACH misses nano! The new chemical legislation of the EU, REACH, is already in need of updating. Its demands for information concerning substance and production volume misses many nan... Is REACH enough? Several investigations show that a large proportion of the ca 70,000 industrial chemicals on the European market lack fundamental data regarding their toxicity. One ... After REACH: What do we do now? Despite the new EU chemical legislation, it may in some cases be difficult to make high quality hazard assessments that are anchored in actual conditions. There are ... Remote controlled camera and genetic technology reveal the fate of the deep Knowledge of our marine environments is decades behind – but research is now beginning in earnest. Just now, there are extensive investments in marine research. New ... Will the Baltic Sea have sustainable management? Eutrophication, decrease in biodiversity, overfishing, toxic chemicals, environmentally hazardous marine transport: Without a doubt, the Baltic Sea is an environment... Models for the health of the Baltic Sea Baltic Nest Institute describes the flux of nutrients in the Baltic Sea drainage basin and builds models for the effects of these in the sea. International marine en... Climate neutral energy One quarter of the energy that is annually used in Sweden comes from bioenergy. Most of this originates from forestry. Crops and processed biofuels from forest raw... New forms of governance in environmental policy Society today has three dominant forms of governance: legislation, market control and network governance. These are particularly noticeable in environmental policy. ... Permafrost - to be or not to be Permafrost is a hot subject. One quarter of the northern hemisphere is permanently frozen. Regions both with and without infrastructure will be affected when the per...

The Interview

Favourable conditions for global collaboration The most complex matter that humanity has discussed. This is how Lars Erik Liljelund, Director General of the Cabinet Office who is responsible for coordination of t... The air, the Baltic Sea and the climate A strengthened European framework directive for air quality, the Baltic Sea as pilot area for the EU marine directive and, what is most urgent, data for the climate...

More articles

The countryside has great potential The countryside and the green sector have special conditions for sustainable economic growth. The countryside is at present dominated by agricultural industries and ... New activities in the forest The importance of family forestry for the countryside and the local economy has decreased. It is managed at a distance and through others. The forest is not the base... The "invisible" population of the countryside Overnight stays in the more than 500,000 second homes in Sweden account for one quarter of all the nights spent away from one's home. Nordic experiences indicate tha... Consultative panels invigorate the countryside No decisions without consultation. Water management in Sweden in 2004 is our model for implementing the European Water Framework Directive. It is based on consultati... There are no philosophers in research for society On a bleak November day Sustainability meets Ola Engelmark, the MD of MISTRA, to have a talk on the mantra "research results belong to society". He has just come bac...

In brief

Environmental classification – on the way to implementation in Sweden How is environmental classification of buildings to be achieved in Sweden? This was the subject of a Formas seminar during the Swedish energy meeting in March. Study of the immune system of horses Formas has given the National Veterinary Institute SVA over 1 million kronor for a period of two years for the study of horses' interferon system. This is an importa... Study of the prehistory of plants In all plants whose genome has been studied in detail, there are genes that have been duplicated in the course of evolution. This is a phenomenon that has promoted t... Diatoms provide information on ecosystems and the climate Diatoms are not only beautiful. The fossil diatoms also provide information on environmental history in the past, for instance that ecosystems in a French lake and i... Sweden rehearses for the presidency of EU In July, the Swedish presidency arranges a major conference in Lund on European research policy issues. Isotopes reveal the feeding habits of toxic algae Algal blooms in the Baltic Sea proliferate because of discharges of nitrogen and phosphorus. But the toxic golden algae not only absorb nitrogen and phosphorus from ... Indicator environments in alpine regions and their sensitivity to climate changes The alpine ecosystem and its biodiversity are facing drastic changes as a consequence of the ongoing climate change. Forecasts from the UN Climate Panel IPCC show th... The use of PICT (induced tolerance) for monitoring the toxic effect of organic compounds on the soil microorganism community In order to determine whether a compound is toxic in nature, it is in most cases not enough to study how individual species react to this compound under controlled c... Incineration for energy recovery Incineration for energy recovery produces large quantities of bottom ash and pulverised fly ash, totalling ca 1,300,000 tonnes annually in Sweden. Memorandum of Understanding In December 2005, Sweden and India signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) for cooperation in science and technology. Another MoU on sustainable development and e...

Results from research

The city as society's arena How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... The changing landscape How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... The cultural heritage of the forest How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... Fibre plants - strength and safety How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... Nanotechnology needs careful consideration How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... Do not cross ecological tipping points! How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma... Stressed fish are not healthy How did the research turn out? What were the findings? Researchers themselves report briefly on the research they have undertaken with funding support from the Forma...

Further links

Footer