Sustainability Issue #2 April 2012

This is printed from, last updated 3/14/2012 5:59:13 PM


Change language


Main content

PrintPrint Print all articlesPrint
Bioenergy, climate and economy

Forest resources. A research project at Centre for Environmental and Resource Economics at Umeå is studying the economical and ecological aspects of energy and climate policy, specifically the change from fossil fuels to renewable fuels.  Photo: W. Wirth / DPA / SCANPIX

Consider everything at the same time:

Bioenergy, climate and economy

By Tommy Lundgren and Per-Olov Marklund

Forest and economy in balance. Can this be achieved? What changes can be expected in forestry if the forest is to sequestrate more carbon dioxide? Does the change from fossil fuels to biofuels promote our welfare? Equilibrium and a holistic approach are the guiding principles for the SLU (Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences) environmental and natural resource researchers in Umeå.

We are facing drastic measures if we are to be able to achieve the energy and climate objectives we have set for ourselves. And we need models so that we can, in a holistic perspective, analyse the effects of the large scale changes in the energy system that are expected. The general aim of our research project “Bioenergy, climate and economy” is to contribute to the development of the types of model that can be used as a reference in designing energy and climate policies.

In most studies, for example, no consideration is given to the carbon cycle as a whole, and this can give rise to erroneous decisions concerning measures if they are based on the results of the studies. These and other deficiencies, and the haste to do something about global warming, form the basis to our research project.

Development of models

More specifically, we will develop both theoretical and empirical models which, in a correct manner, take account of the interplay of economy and ecology. For example, a general equilibrium model will be developed so that we can simulate the effects on society and sectors in different environmental and energy politics scenarios, the objectives of which are to promote climate and sustainable use of bioenergy.

So far, the project has generated a doctoral thesis and a number of articles. In the thesis, a study is made of the sequestration of carbon dioxide in the forest, which is attracting increasing interest in the policy debate. Technically, there are several ways of increasing this sequestration.  It is possible, for instance, to enlarge the forest area, change the management of existing forests, extend the life of wood products and use more bioenergy . Attention must however be paid to changes in silviculture and the use of biomass in industry.

The doctoral thesis presents a computable general equilibrium model (Computable General Equilibrium, CGE) in which the economy and ecology interact. The ecological model is a growth model that describes the dynamics of a forest where an explicit harvesting strategy exists and is determined in the model. An evaluation is made here of the probable effects of economic policy measures which may potentially be introduced to promote carbon sequestration in the forest.

Three scenarios

We take a closer look at three scenarios:

Scenario No 1. Compensation is given to forest owners because CO2 is sequestrated in new growth, and because they are taxed because CO2 is emitted during harvesting (symmetry).

Scenario No 2. In addition to the measures applied in Scenario No 1, forest owners receive tax rebates  depending on the products for which the harvest is used, and on the length of time these products prevent emission of CO2  into the atmosphere  (product sequestration).

Scenario No 3. In addition to the measures applied in Scenarios Nos 1 and 2, forest owners who save GROT (branches G and crowns T) and stumps in the forest receive tax rebates.

The results indicate that the cost to society of these scenarios would be greater in the beginning of the planning horizon, since there may be a considerable delay before there is a significant increase in the sequestration of carbon in the forest.

The analysis shows that the use of biomass will probably move from the pulp industry to the wood industry, because of differences in age specific types of biomass that are used in different parts of the industry. This seems reasonable, since a policy that stimulates sequestration of CO2 increases the age of the forest.

The results also indicate that such a sequestration policy would result in resources being transferred to forest owners from other economic actors. These transfers will probably be increased further if tax concessions have already been established. The model shows that the introduction of tax rebates increases the social costs of an environmental policy that focuses on the sequestration of CO2.

Why biofuels?

Is it possible to formulate a clear overall conclusion with regard to e.g. the climatic effect?

Biofuels are seen as energy sources with the potential to solve different problems connected with climate changes, environmental destruction, energy supply and energy security. In an article we discuss biofuels, primarily biofuels for transport, such as ethanol and biodiesel, from a welfare perspective and address a fundamental question: Why biofuels?

A survey of the literature shows that the effects of  a policy that promotes transition from fossil fuels to biofuels does not necessarily promote welfare. Our theoretical framework gives indications of possible reasons for this. On the basis of our model, we are proposing a policy that not only taxes the emission of CO2 from all types of sources – including biofuels – but also favours the growth of biomass, which implies that growth is subsidised.

With the help of a theoretical growth model that comprises environment and climate related external effects, we take a closer look at the welfare effects of stimulating biomass growth and increasing the use of bioenergy. As an illustration, we make use of a hypothetical intensive cultivation project, MINT. It is important that we calculate not only the positive effects of promoting growth and using bioenergy, such as the substitution away from fossil fuels and carbon sequestration. It is also important – in order to arrive at a balanced measure of the effects on the climate – that we also incorporate all the carbon dioxide emissions that are associated with bioenergy. Unless this is done, we will overestimate the positive climatic effects of increasing the use of bioenergy and stimulating growth. This is particularly important for slow growing biomass, such as Swedish forest that has a rotation of 50-100 years.

Cost-revenue analysis

A current study presents a systematic method for studying the socio-economic revenues and costs of introducing intensified management measures in forestry. Changes in wood production are evaluated, as well as various types of external effects such as the impact on recreation, acidification and carbon balance. The model is exemplified with the help of data from the Swedish state MINT investigation from 2009 that examined the impact on the Swedish forest sector of intensified silviculture methods.

Our cost-revenue analysis shows that intensified management measures are normally cost effective from the standpoint of private economics. Whether these measures will also be profitable from the standpoint of society depends on the magnitude of the external effects inclusive of carbon balance.

Author :

Tommy Lundgren is researcher at Centre for Environmental and Resource Economics, CERE, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences SLU, Umeå

Per-Olov Marklund is researcher at Centre for Environmental and Resource Economics, CERE, Umeå University


Ö. Furtenback (2011) “Three essays on Swedish energy and climate policy options – dynamic CGE-models with heterogeneous forests and econometric model of fuel substitution in district heating plants” (doktorsavhandling, SLU - Umeå).

T. Lundgren, P-O. Marklund, Brännlund, R., B. Kriström, (2008/2009), ”The Economics of Biofuels”, International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics, Vol 2, 237-280.

Lundgren, T., P-O. Marklund (2011), “Assessing the welfare effects of promoting biomass growth and the use of bioenergy – A simple back-of-an-envelope calculation.” WP 11-2011, Centre for Environmental and Resource Economics,

Brännlund, R., O. Carlén, Lundgren, T., P-O. Marklund (2011). ”The costs and benefits of intensive forest management”. WP 12-2011, Centre for Environmental and Resource Economics,

Responsible for this page: Birgitta Bruzelius

Journal links

Sustainability April 2012

Focus presentation

Economy based on plants Sweden must use natural resources more effectively, and the economy must be based on renewable raw materials that are produced through a sustainable use of ecosystem...

Focus articles

Reinvigorated economy is growing again Society is facing serious challenges in counteracting and adapting to climate changes. There are hopes now for a sustainable use of renewable products and energy tha... It’s the bio-economy, stupid! The bio-economy represents a significant shift in socio-economic, agricultural, energy and technical systems. The concept of the bio-economy – also called the bio-ba... Forest biotechnology clears the way for a biobased society During the war years in the 1940s, different chemicals could already be synthesised from ethanol. We must perhaps rediscover some of this old knowledge and at the sa... Replace plastics and aluminium Conventional oil-based plastics can be replaced. Not least in packaging where a good barrier against e.g. oxygen or water extends shelf life and helps preserve the f... Lignin – the future source of fine chemicals Environmental gains today – growth in the long run. The transition from petroleum based chemical processes to bioprocesses based on renewable raw materials provides... Plants take up organic nitrogen Is this the time to rewrite textbooks? Many people write about nitrate and ammonium as the two nitrogen compounds which plants take up through their roots and use fo... Bioenergy, climate and economy Forest and economy in balance. Can this be achieved? What changes can be expected in forestry if the forest is to sequestrate more carbon dioxide? Does the change fr...

The Interview

Lena Ek: Research key to successful environmental policy –I feel so full of energy when I meet people who are working in research and development. This is how Minister of Environment Lena Ek concluded this interview where,...

More articles

Gastric ailments because of the water? Can heavy rain and bursts in water mains give us gastric ailments? This is being investigated at present by researchers at Umeå and Göteborg. They have already found... Sewage treatment plants reveal how we use chemicals Sewage treatment plants reveal how we use chemicals. Chemicals can load the environment via the treated water or sewage sludge. A recent thesis at Umeå University sh... Large climatic differences between biofuels When biofuels are burned, the carbon dioxide that was at one time bound in the tree is emitted into the atmosphere. Bioenergy is therefore often described as carbon ... This is how biogas can be produced better It is known that the addition of trace metals can improve biogas production. A recent thesis at Linköping University shows which metals these are and how to apply t... Development of “green coal” from biomass Torrefaction means that biomass is heated to a temperature of 250-350°C in the absence of oxygen. This is being studied by a research team at Umeå University which h... Make more use of wave power The oceans of the world offer a renewable source of electric power that is measured in terawatt, which is 1012 watt, i.e. 1000 gigawatt. Surface gravity waves are co... Environmentally labelled fish launches a new era Bycatch is reduced, and more marine protected areas are created. These are some of the results which environmental labelling of fish and fisheries have provided. Environmental toxins indoors We spend about 90 per cent of our time indoors. New research from Stockholm University shows that we are exposed to environmental toxins to a higher degree in our ho... Computer models complement animal experiments A thesis in Chemistry at Umeå University shows the potential of using computer models as tools in obtaining information for the hazard assessment of industrial chemi... Sustainable towns all round Sweden More than 200 people filled the dance floor at Nalen at 74 Regeringsgatan in Stockholm one winter day in 2012. But it was not a dance but a gathering of engaged peop...

In brief

Ozone contaminates crops all over the world Almost seven million tonnes of wheat. More than eleven million tonnes of rice. This is what is destroyed annually in South-East Asia because of the contamination cau... The viviparous blenny acts as a warning signal for the Baltic Sea The little viviparous blenny is the new warning signal for the Baltic Sea. It plays an important part in monitoring the state of the sea. One of the results of recen... This is why British thoroughbreds are fastest Genetic data from Shetland ponies was the piece of puzzle that was missing. Researchers now understand why British thoroughbreds run so much faster and longer than o... Recovery of phosphorus from algae Algae that have been washed up onto land may become useful. In February 2012, Swedish Environmental Research Institute IVL began a full scale pilot project at Trelle... Let animals graze Many factors affect the appearance of the landscape. New research from Stockholm University shows that the preservation and enhancement of biodiversity demands clear... Live longer with fewer calories By eating fewer calories, we can slow down ageing, and age related diseases such as cancer and Type 2 diabetes can be put off. The earlier we reduce the intake of ca...

People and News

The latest from the field of environmental researchNew appointments, prestigious awards, new research institutes – all the latest from the field of environmental research.

Further links